Thriving in the era of overchoice

Thriving in the era of overchoice

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.

Leonardo da Vinci

In the world of leadership, the pursuit of excellence drives leaders to seek more – more options, more tasks and more responsibilities. However, this relentless quest can overload the decision-making process, making leaders stressed and stealing away genuine happiness and inner peace. Leaders, responsible for critical decisions, must recognise the difficulties caused by having too many options. By understanding how this abundance impacts them and their teams, leaders can lead with greater clarity, focus and empathy – like fine-tuning a camera for a perfect picture.

Challenge of Overchoice:

Psychological research, especially Sheena Iyengar’s work, shows that having too many choices can make decision-making hard. Iyengar’s study on the assortment of jams in a supermarket showed that while an extensive selection attracted more attention, a limited selection resulted in significantly more purchases. This study underscores how an abundance of choices can induce decision paralysis, ultimately reducing satisfaction with the chosen option.

Furthermore, Schwartz and colleagues’ study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that many choices can cause more regret and less satisfaction with decisions. This shows how having too many choices can affect us psychologically.

As mentioned earlier, overchoice also leads to decision fatigue. Research by Roy F. Baumeister and John Tierney in “Willpower: Rediscovering the Greatest Human Strength” has demonstrated that making many decisions can drain mental energy, resulting in lower self-control and rational decision-making abilities.

These research findings bolster the argument that the burden of overchoice can indeed hinder decision-making and overall well-being, underscoring the importance of strategies for mitigating overchoice such as embracing minimalism, delegation, and mindfulness.

Simplifying Choices
To counteract the negative effects of overchoice, leaders can simplify their decision-making by embracing minimalism. Minimalism, found across various cultures, encourages focusing on what’s essential and discarding what’s unnecessary. It’s the idea that “less is more.” Leaders can use minimalism by streamlining their decision-making processes and focusing on core goals.

Think of it as trimming a bonsai tree. By carefully pruning away unnecessary branches, the tree becomes more beautiful and vibrant.

For example, imagine an executive tasked with developing a new product line. Instead of creating numerous options, they may choose to concentrate on a few products with unique value. This approach aligns with the idea of “satisficing”, where the aim is to achieve satisfactory results rather than seeking perfection. By doing this, leaders can reduce the overwhelming effects of overchoice and make decisions more clearly.

In a world of endless choices, leaders must learn to say ‘No’. It’s not a weakness but a way to protect their time and energy. Leaders who do this can focus on what really matters, cut distractions, and avoid decision fatigue. By choosing where to invest their efforts wisely, they achieve more by clearing away what holds them back.

Saying ‘No’ is like decluttering your workspace. It creates space for what truly matters and enhances productivity.

Delegating Wisely
Another effective strategy to reduce the impact of overchoice is smart delegation. Research in adult development, like Kegan’s constructive-developmental theory, suggests that people become better at handling complex tasks as they grow. Leaders can use this knowledge to delegate tasks strategically, assigning them to team members based on their growth stage. This empowers them to take responsibility and contribute meaningfully.

For example, imagine a leader overseeing a complex project. They can assign specific parts of the project to team members depending on their developmental stages. Team members who are still developing may handle simpler tasks, while those at more advanced stages can manage more complicated responsibilities. This not only spreads the workload but also helps team members develop their skills and feel a sense of purpose, which ultimately benefits the leader’s inner peace.

When dealing with overchoice, mindfulness provides a practical guide for leaders. Mindfulness, rooted in philosophies like Buddhism, acts as a tool to clear the fog from the decision-making lens. It helps leaders stay in the present moment, be aware of their thoughts and emotions, and navigate the sea of choices with a clear mind.

For example, consider an executive facing numerous strategic options. To make decisions with greater clarity and less emotional interference, they can use mindfulness techniques. This might involve taking a moment to breathe deeply, focusing on the present, and calmly observing their thoughts and feelings before delving into the decision-making process.


Incorporating research strengthens the argument about overchoice. Studies in psychology confirm that overchoice negatively affects decision-making and satisfaction. Moreover, practical strategies like minimalism, delegation and mindfulness help leaders tackle overchoice. By using these strategies, leaders not only improve their own well-being but also motivate their teams in a world full of change and endless choices.

Just as a photographer skilfully adjusts their camera settings to capture the essence of a scene, leaders can fine-tune their filters of choice to bring clarity to their decision-making.

About Ramesh Nair

Ramesh is a seasoned Certified Leadership coach, Digital Strategist, and C-suite advisor with a proven track record of leading successful transformations in F500 companies. He has over 30 years of experience in the technology industry, and has led divisions generating over $300 million in revenue. He is also an expert in scaling technology delivery organisations, and has extensive experience in the US market. He understands that true transformation requires a growth mindset, and he creates a safe and confidential space for leaders to explore their setbacks, opportunities, aspirations, and career paths. He liberates them from growth-inhibiting mindsets and empowers them to reach their full potential.

Leave a Reply